Short-Term vs Long-Term Letting
In today’s dynamic property market, landlords must choose between two main rental strategies: short-term and long-term letting. Both offer unique financial advantages and operational challenges, particularly within South Africa’s shifting regulatory environment.
Understanding which option aligns best with your goals can make the difference between strong returns and high risk. This guide compares profitability, legal obligations, and risk factors to help South African landlords decide which strategy best suits them.
Understanding Short-Term Letting
Short-term letting involves renting a property for days or weeks at a time, often through platforms such as Airbnb, Booking.com, or similar online marketplaces.
These rentals target tourists, corporate travellers, and holidaymakers seeking furnished accommodation with flexible check-in options.
Landlords offering short-term lets often earn higher monthly gross income, but they face frequent tenant turnover, seasonal demand fluctuations, and greater operational involvement.
Benefits of Short-Term Letting
Short-term rentals can deliver impressive returns when managed effectively, especially in high-demand cities like Cape Town, Durban, and Johannesburg. Key advantages include:
- Higher income potential: Daily rates often exceed monthly rent from long leases.
- Flexibility: The landlord can use the property personally during vacant periods.
- Dynamic pricing: Rates can adjust for holidays, events, or seasonal demand.
- Faster cash flow: Payments are usually processed before or at check-in.
For landlords near tourist attractions or business hubs, short-term letting may seem ideal. However, success depends on location, occupancy rates, and professional management.
Drawbacks of Short-Term Letting
Despite the appeal, short-term letting carries greater operational and financial risk:
- Frequent vacancies: Inconsistent occupancy can hurt monthly income.
- Higher maintenance costs: Frequent guest turnover leads to wear and tear.
- Time-intensive management: Cleaning, check-ins, and guest communication are ongoing.
- Regulatory limits: Some municipalities now require short-term rental registration or licensing.
- Increased utilities and service costs: Landlords cover Wi-Fi, electricity, and cleaning.
Without careful management, these costs can offset the benefits of higher rental rates.
Understanding Long-Term Letting
Long-term letting involves leasing the property for six months or longer under a formal lease agreement governed by the Rental Housing Act. This approach prioritises stability and predictable income rather than rapid returns.
Landlords who use this model attract working professionals, families, and students seeking reliable accommodation and a steady foundation for sustainable property investment.
Benefits of Long-Term Letting
Long-term letting offers simplicity and stability. It remains the preferred choice for landlords seeking reliable income with minimal effort. Advantages include:
- Predictable cash flow: Rent is consistent and easy to forecast monthly.
- Lower management effort: Fewer tenant turnovers mean reduced administrative work.
- Lower maintenance costs: Tenants often treat the property like their own home.
- Easier compliance: Long leases are subject to well-established laws under the Rental Housing Act.
- Reduced vacancy risk: Especially in suburban or residential markets.
For many landlords, the security of long-term tenants outweighs the excitement and volatility of short-term rentals.
Drawbacks of Long-Term Letting
Although stable, long-term leases limit flexibility and profit potential in specific markets. Common challenges include:
- Slower rent increases: Leases usually fix rent for 12 months, with limited annual escalation.
- Difficulty removing problem tenants: Eviction processes can be lengthy and costly.
- Less control over property use: The property cannot easily switch between tenant and personal use.
- Depreciation over time: Fixed tenants may cause gradual wear without immediate inspection opportunities.
Still, for landlords focused on consistent returns, long-term letting remains a strong, low-risk strategy.
Regulations Affecting Short-Term and Long-Term Letting
South Africa’s regulatory landscape is evolving rapidly, and landlords must ensure full compliance with local laws.
For short-term letting, municipalities such as Cape Town and Johannesburg now require:
- Business or zoning approval for transient accommodation.
- Registration or licensing of Airbnb-style properties.
- Payment of tourism levies and income tax on rental earnings.
For long-term letting, compliance includes:
- Written lease agreements under the Rental Housing Act.
- Deposit management and property inspections.
- Adherence to the Consumer Protection Act for early lease cancellations.
Failing to meet these obligations can result in penalties, fines, or legal disputes, particularly for short-term hosts.
Profitability Comparison
Profitability depends on location, property type, and management efficiency.
- In coastal or tourist regions, short-term letting can yield up to 30–50% higher annual income — but only at high occupancy levels.
- In urban residential areas, long-term letting offers steady yields of 8–10% with lower costs and risks.
- Short-term rentals require active marketing, cleaning, and management fees (10–20% of gross income).
- Long-term rentals entail lower variable costs but slower income growth.
Landlords should calculate net yield, not just gross revenue, when deciding which strategy works best for South African landlords.
Risk and Management Considerations
Short-term letting risk factors:
- Irregular income due to seasonality.
- Potential property damage from short stays.
- Higher insurance premiums.
- Stricter municipal compliance requirements.
Long-term letting risk factors:
- Tenant arrears and possible eviction proceedings.
- Lower rental growth during economic slowdowns.
- Long vacancy periods between leases in weaker markets.
Risk management should include proper insurance, written leases, tenant vetting, and regular inspections for both models.
Which Strategy Works Best for South African Landlords?
The right choice depends on your financial goals, location, and risk tolerance.
- Choose short-term letting if your property is in a high-demand tourist or business zone, and you can manage or outsource frequent turnover efficiently.
- Choose long-term letting if you value stability, predictability, and minimal hands-on involvement.
In 2025, a hybrid approach is gaining popularity, with landlords renting short-term during peak seasons and switching to long-term leases during off-peak months. This flexible model maximises yield while maintaining occupancy.
Ultimately, success depends on strategic planning and compliance with all legal and municipal requirements.
FAQs
Which rental model is more profitable?
Short-term letting can deliver higher gross income, but costs and vacancies often reduce net yield. Long-term letting offers steadier profit and easier management.
Do I need special approval for Airbnb in South Africa?
Yes, in most municipalities, you must register or obtain zoning consent for short-term rentals.
Can I switch between short and long-term letting?
Yes. Many landlords adopt a hybrid model, short-term during busy months and long-term when demand slows.
What laws govern long-term leases?
The Rental Housing Act and Consumer Protection Act regulate long leases, deposits, and tenant rights.
Which is safer — short-term or long-term tenants?
Long-term tenants provide greater financial security and legal clarity, while short-term guests require more frequent management.
Don’t go through it alone — South Africa’s landlords stand together.
When you join the Landlords Association of South Africa, you gain more than just membership; you gain a robust network of support. From expert legal advice and vital landlord resources to guidance on dealing with problem tenants, we stand with you every step of the way.
For just 2 rand a day, you can access professional advice, proven tools, and a community that understands the challenges of both commercial and residential property management.
Join today and experience the confidence of knowing you’re never facing it alone.
Our Top Read Blogs:
How to Sell a House in South Africa Fast
Complete Process of Tenant Eviction in South Africa
What Can I Do If A Tenant Is Neglecting My Property
Useful External Links
Disclaimer:
This post is for general use only and is not intended to offer legal, tax, or investment advice; it may be out of date, incorrect, or maybe a guest post. You are required to seek legal advice from a solicitor before acting on anything written hereinabove.
